BGuthrie Photos: NPC -- Kalb Report: "We the People..." (w/Nina Totenberg, Pete Williams, and Jonathan Turley)

NPC -- Kalb Report: "We the People..." (w/Nina Totenberg, Pete Williams, and Jonathan Turley):

Bruce Guthrie Photos Home Page: [Click here] to go to Bruce Guthrie Photos home page.

Description of Pictures: The Kalb Report: “We the People…”
Is America headed for—or perhaps already in -- a constitutional crisis fueled by highly partisan politics? Is this endangering our democracy? If so, where do we go from here?
The first forum in the 26th season of The Kalb Report (and the 100th program in the series) will tackle these questions as well as examine who we are as a country today, how we are influencing the world and whether the current administration is an anomaly or represents a dramatic shift in our ideology.
Joining moderator Marvin Kalb will be NPR Legal Affairs Correspondent Nina Totenberg, NBC News Justice Correspondent Pete Williams and George Washington University Constitutional Law Professor and CBS News Analyst Jonathan Turley.
The Kalb Report series is underwritten by a grant from Ethics and Excellence in Journalism Foundation. Maryland Public Television serves as presenting station.

Recognize anyone? If you recognize specific folks (or other stuff) and I haven't labeled them, please identify them for the world. Click the little pencil icon

underneath the file name (just above the picture). Spammers need not apply.

Copyrights: All pictures were taken by amateur photographer Bruce Guthrie (me!) who retains copyright on them. Free for non-commercial use with attribution. See the [Creative Commons] definition of what this means. "Photos (c) Bruce Guthrie" is fine for attribution. (Commercial use folks including AI scrapers can of course contact me.) Feel free to use in publications and pages with attribution but you don't have permission to sell the photos themselves. A free copy of any printed publication using any photographs is requested. Descriptive text, if any, is from a mixture of sources, quite frequently from signs at the location or from official web sites; copyrights, if any, are retained by their original owners.

Accessing as Spider: The system has identified your IP as being a spider.
IP Address: 18.118.195.162 -- Domain: Amazon Technologies
I love well-behaved spiders! They are, in fact, how most people find my site. Unfortunately, my network has a limited bandwidth and pictures take up bandwidth. Spiders ask for lots and lots of pages and chew up lots and lots of bandwidth which slows things down considerably for regular folk. To counter this, you'll see all the text on the page but the images are being suppressed. Also, some system options like merges are being blocked for you.
Note: Permission is NOT granted for spiders, robots, etc to use the site for AI-generation purposes. I'm sure you're thrilled by your ability to make revenue from my work but there's nothing in that for my human users or for me.
If you are in fact human, please email me at guthrie.bruce@gmail.com and I can check if your designation was made in error. Given your number of hits, that's unlikely but what the hell.

Help? The Medium (Email) links are for screen viewing and emailing. You'll want bigger sizes for printing. [Click here for additional help]

[1] KALB1_191204_001_STITCH.JPG

[2] KALB1_191204_003_STITCH.JPG

[3] KALB1_191204_004_STITCH.JPG

[4] KALB1_191204_005_STITCH.JPG

[5] KALB1_191204_006_STITCH.JPG

[6] KALB1_191204_008_STITCH.JPG

[7] KALB1_191204_010_STITCH.JPG

[8] KALB1_191204_014_STITCH.JPG

[9] KALB1_191204_017_STITCH.JPG

[10] KALB1_191204_019.JPG	[11] KALB1_191204_020.JPG
[12] KALB1_191204_021.JPG	[13] KALB1_191204_023.JPG
[14] KALB1_191204_025.JPG	[15] KALB1_191204_027.JPG
[16] KALB1_191204_041.JPG	[17] KALB1_191204_042.JPG
[18] KALB1_191204_044.JPG	[19] KALB1_191204_049.JPG
[20] KALB1_191204_063.JPG	[21] KALB1_191204_065.JPG
[22] KALB1_191204_067.JPG	[23] KALB1_191204_072.JPG
[24] KALB1_191204_075.JPG	[25] KALB1_191204_086.JPG
[26] KALB1_191204_113.JPG	[27] KALB1_191204_122.JPG
[28] KALB1_191204_139.JPG	[29] KALB1_191204_141.JPG
[30] KALB1_191204_152.JPG	[31] KALB1_191204_156.JPG
[32] KALB1_191204_160.JPG	[33] KALB1_191204_164.JPG
[34] KALB1_191204_170.JPG	[35] KALB1_191204_173.JPG
[36] KALB1_191204_189.JPG	[37] KALB1_191204_193.JPG
[38] KALB1_191204_200.JPG	[39] KALB1_191204_208.JPG
[40] KALB1_191204_213.JPG	[41] KALB1_191204_218.JPG
[42] KALB1_191204_220.JPG	[43] KALB1_191204_224.JPG
[44] KALB1_191204_232.JPG	[45] KALB1_191204_251.JPG
[46] KALB1_191204_253.JPG	[47] KALB1_191204_262.JPG
[48] KALB1_191204_267.JPG	[49] KALB1_191204_288.JPG
[50] KALB1_191204_293.JPG	[51] KALB1_191204_297.JPG
[52] KALB1_191204_302.JPG	[53] KALB1_191204_304.JPG
[54] KALB1_191204_309.JPG	[55] KALB1_191204_311.JPG
[56] KALB1_191204_321.JPG	[57] KALB1_191204_331.JPG
[58] KALB1_191204_352.JPG	[59] KALB1_191204_363.JPG
[60] KALB1_191204_373.JPG	[61] KALB1_191204_379.JPG
[62] KALB1_191204_382.JPG	[63] KALB1_191204_386.JPG
[64] KALB1_191204_403.JPG	[65] KALB1_191204_440.JPG
[66] KALB1_191204_451.JPG	[67] KALB1_191204_454.JPG
[68] KALB1_191204_473.JPG	[69] KALB1_191204_476.JPG
[70] KALB1_191204_537.JPG	[71] KALB1_191204_539.JPG
[72] KALB1_191204_570.JPG	[73] KALB1_191204_595.JPG
[74] KALB1_191204_603.JPG	[75] KALB1_191204_646.JPG
[76] KALB1_191204_653.JPG	[77] KALB1_191204_665.JPG
[78] KALB2_191204_017.JPG	[79] KALB2_191204_026.JPG
[80] KALB2_191204_039.JPG	[81] KALB2_191204_046.JPG
[82] KALB2_191204_054.JPG	[83] KALB2_191204_057.JPG
[84] KALB2_191204_061.JPG	[85] KALB2_191204_069.JPG
[86] KALB2_191204_114.JPG	[87] KALB2_191204_125.JPG
[88] KALB2_191204_143.JPG	[89] KALB2_191204_147.JPG
[90] KALB2_191204_151.JPG	[91] KALB2_191204_158.JPG
[92] KALB2_191204_177.JPG	[93] KALB2_191204_189.JPG
[94] KALB2_191204_195.JPG	[95] KALB2_191204_197.JPG
[96] KALB2_191204_199.JPG	[97] KALB2_191204_225.JPG
[98] KALB2_191204_227.JPG	[99] KALB2_191204_259.JPG
[100] KALB2_191204_273.JPG	[101] KALB2_191204_279.JPG
[102] KALB2_191204_286.JPG	[103] KALB2_191204_289.JPG
[104] KALB2_191204_300.JPG	[105] KALB2_191204_307.JPG
[106] KALB2_191204_320.JPG	[107] KALB2_191204_330.JPG
[108] KALB2_191204_365.JPG	[109] KALB2_191204_373.JPG
[110] KALB2_191204_376.JPG	[111] KALB2_191204_378.JPG
[112] KALB2_191204_393.JPG	[113] KALB2_191204_412.JPG
[114] KALB2_191204_423.JPG	[115] KALB2_191204_426.JPG
[116] KALB2_191204_439.JPG	[117] KALB2_191204_458.JPG
[118] KALB2_191204_471.JPG	[119] KALB2_191204_476.JPG
[120] KALB2_191204_484.JPG	[121] KALB2_191204_493.JPG
[122] KALB2_191204_506.JPG	[123] KALB2_191204_517.JPG
[124] KALB2_191204_543.JPG	[125] KALB2_191204_553.JPG
[126] KALB2_191204_555.JPG	[127] KALB2_191204_572.JPG
[128] KALB2_191204_574.JPG	[129] KALB2_191204_576.JPG
[130] KALB2_191204_578.JPG	[131] KALB2_191204_580.JPG
[132] KALB2_191204_582.JPG	[133] KALB2_191204_586.JPG
[134] KALB2_191204_588.JPG	[135] KALB2_191204_590.JPG
[136] KALB2_191204_592.JPG	[137] KALB2_191204_596.JPG
[138] KALB2_191204_597.JPG	[139] KALB2_191204_598.JPG
[140] KALB2_191204_601.JPG	[141] KALB2_191204_603.JPG
[142] KALB2_191204_605.JPG	[143] KALB2_191204_611.JPG
[144] KALB2_191204_614.JPG	[145] KALB2_191204_616.JPG
[146] KALB2_191204_618.JPG	[147] KALB2_191204_619.JPG
[148] KALB2_191204_620.JPG	[149] KALB2_191204_621.JPG
[150] KALB2_191204_622.JPG	[151] KALB2_191204_623.JPG
[152] KALB2_191204_624.JPG	[153] KALB2_191204_625.JPG

Specific picture descriptions: Photos above with "i" icons next to the bracketed sequence numbers (e.g. "[1] ") are described as follows:
1. KALB1_191204_019.JPG: Bernard Kalb
2. KALB1_191204_020.JPG: Bernard Kalb, Claudia Kalb, and family
3. KALB1_191204_023.JPG: Steve Mukherjee
4. KALB1_191204_025.JPG: Stephen Joel Trachtenberg (right)
5. KALB1_191204_041.JPG: Nina Totenberg
6. KALB1_191204_044.JPG: Jonathan Turley
7. KALB1_191204_049.JPG: Pete Williams
8. KALB1_191204_063.JPG: Stephen Trachtenberg, Bernard Kalb
9. KALB1_191204_065.JPG: Stephen Trachtenberg, Bernard Kalb
10. KALB1_191204_067.JPG: Stephen Trachtenberg, Bernard Kalb
11. KALB1_191204_122.JPG: Bernard Kalb, Stephen Trachtenberg, Pete Williams
12. KALB1_191204_141.JPG: Jonathan Turley
13. KALB1_191204_152.JPG: Pete Williams, Lindsay Underwood
14. KALB1_191204_156.JPG: Lindsay Underwood, Pete Williams, Nina Totenberg, Marvin Kalb, Jonathan Turley
15. KALB1_191204_160.JPG: Marvin Kalb
16. KALB1_191204_173.JPG: Gilbert Klein
17. KALB1_191204_189.JPG: Heather Date, Mike Freedman
18. KALB1_191204_200.JPG: Mike Freedman
19. KALB1_191204_232.JPG: Myron Belkind (right)
20. KALB1_191204_251.JPG: Jonathan Turley, Mike Freedman
21. KALB1_191204_288.JPG: Jonathan Turley, Mike Freedman
22. KALB1_191204_297.JPG: Marvin Kalb, Mike Freedman, Stephen Trachtenberg
23. KALB1_191204_311.JPG: Pete Williams, Nina Totenberg, Marvin Kalb, Jonathan Turley
24. KALB1_191204_382.JPG: Nina Totenberg
25. KALB2_191204_125.JPG: Marvin Kalb, Jonathan Turley
26. KALB2_191204_279.JPG: Edward R. Murrow, Nina Totenberg
27. KALB2_191204_307.JPG: Marvin Kalb
28. KALB2_191204_555.JPG: Marvin Kalb, Jonathan Turley
29. KALB2_191204_572.JPG: Bernard Kalb, Jonathan Turley
30. KALB2_191204_576.JPG: Marvin Kalb, Bernard Kalb
31. KALB2_191204_578.JPG: Bernard Kalb, grandson
32. KALB2_191204_580.JPG: Marvin Kalb, Bernard Kalb
33. KALB2_191204_582.JPG: Nina Totenberg and fans
34. KALB2_191204_592.JPG: Kalb grandson, Claudia Kalb, Phyllis Kalb
35. KALB2_191204_611.JPG: Gil Klein and students
36. KALB2_191204_616.JPG: Myron Belkind, Rachel Belkind
37. KALB2_191204_619.JPG: Myron Belkind, Rachel Belkind, Mike Freedman
38. KALB2_191204_621.JPG: Lindsay Underwood, Mike Freedman
39. KALB2_191204_623.JPG: Gil Klein, Heather Date, Mike Freedman, Lindsay Underwood, Kat Bugg
Description of Subject Matter: The George Washington University, the National Press Club and the Shorenstein Center have produced 51 forums in the The Kalb Report series since 1994. This highly acclaimed public affairs series is hosted by the distinguished journalist/scholar Marvin Kalb. Through one-on-one interviews and panel discussions emanating from the main ballroom of the National Press Club before audiences comprising several hundred students and professionals, Mr. Kalb explores topics ranging from "Ethics in Journalism" to "Covering the Private Lives of Public Officials." Guests have included Walter Cronkite, Dan Rather, Jim Lehrer, Ted Koppel, Sen. Hillary Clinton, Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld, former Secretary of State Madeleine Albright, Nobel Prize winner Elie Wiesel, New York Times Publisher Arthur Sulzberger, Jr., former CBS News President Andrew Heyward, NPR President and CEO Kevin Klose, FOX News Chairman Roger Ailes, CBS News Chief Washington Correspondent Bob Schieffer, New York Times Columnist Thomas Friedman, and Washington Post Writer/Editor Bob Woodward. The Kalb Report airs on XM Public Radio (Channel 133 on XM Satellite Radio), WHUT-TV Channel 32 Public Television, and 630 WMAL Radio in Washington.
Executive producer for The Kalb Report is Mike Freedman, vice president and professorial lecturer in broadcast journalism at GW. The Kalb Report producers are Matt Lindsay and Heather Clapp Date.
In June 2004, the Chesapeake Associated Press Broadcasters Association named The Kalb Report "Best Public Affairs Program" on the radio in the Washington, D.C., region.
The 2005-06 season of The Kalb Report is underwritten by a grant from the Ethics and Excellence in Journalism Foundation.
The above was from their official site at http://www.gwu.edu/~kalb/
Bigger photos? To save server space, the full-sized versions of these images have either not been loaded to the server or have been removed from the server. (Only some pages are loaded with full-sized images and those usually get removed after three months.) I still have them though. If you want me to email them to you, please send an email to guthrie.bruce@gmail.com and I can email them to you, or, depending on the number of images, just repost the page again will the full-sized images.
Featured Folk: Some of the people here can also be seen on other pages on this site.
- Belkind, Myron appears on:
  - 2023_DC_WHHA_TVPres_230124 White House Historical Association -- Panel ("White House History: The Televised Presidency") w/Frank Sesno, Kelly O’Donnell, Mike McCurry, and Dr. Martha Kumar
  - 2019_DC_100AL20_191119 NPC -- 100th Anniversary of the American Legion Post 20
  - 2019_DC_McAuliffe_190801 Politics & Prose -- Terry McAuliffe ("Beyond Charlottesville")
  - 2019_DC_NPC_Vecchio_190730 NPC -- Carlos Vecchio (Accessing Venezuela's political situation)
  - 2019_DC_Kalb_190415 NPC -- Kalb Report: "50th Anniversary of the Apollo 11 Moon Landing" (w/Michael Collins)
  - 2019_DC_Kalb_190401 NPC -- Kalb Report: "A Conversation with Cokie Roberts on Democracy, Politics, and the Press" (w/Cokie Roberts)
  - 2018_DC_WP_WPFI2_180425 Washington Post -- World Press Freedom Index 2018 -- Panel 2: Perspectives w/J. Jesus Esquivel, Jason Rezaian, Alisa Sopova, Margaret Talev, and Dana Priest
  - 2018_DC_WP_WPFI_180425 Washington Post -- World Press Freedom Index 2018 -- Panel 1: Index Presentation w/Margaux Ewen and Karoun Demirjian
  - 2014_DC_Kalb_141020 NPC -- Kalb Report: "Writing History" (w/Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein)
- Freedman, Mike appears on:
  - 2023_DC_Kalb3_230422 NPC -- The Kalb Report Celebration and Lifetime Achievement Award Ceremony -- Everything Else
  - 2023_DC_Kalb_230422 NPC -- The Kalb Report Celebration and Lifetime Achievement Award Ceremony -- Program
  - 2019_DC_100AL20_191119 NPC -- 100th Anniversary of the American Legion Post 20
  - 2019_DC_Bookfair_191101 NPC -- 42nd Annual Book Fair & Author's Night (2019)
  - 2019_DC_Kalb_190415 NPC -- Kalb Report: "50th Anniversary of the Apollo 11 Moon Landing" (w/Michael Collins)
  - 2017_DC_Kalb_171016 NPC -- Kalb Report: "Guardians of the Fourth Estate" (w/Dean Baquet and Marty Baron)
  - 2017_DC_Kalb_170408 NPC -- Kalb Report: "Fight for Freedom of the Press" (w/Jake Tapper and David Fahrenthold)
  - 2016_DC_Kalb_Magic_Hat_160827 NPC -- Deborah Kalb ("George Washington & The Magic Hat in Washington")
  - 2015_DC_Kalb_151109 NPC -- Kalb Report: "Sunday Talk" (w/Chuck Todd and John Dickerson)
  - 2014_DC_Kalb_141020 NPC -- Kalb Report: "Writing History" (w/Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein)
  - ...More (List all 30 pages with this person)...
- Kalb, Bernard appears on:
  - 2019_DC_Kalb_190107 Politics & Prose -- Deborah Kalb and Robert Lunsford ("President and Me: John Adams & the Magic Bobblehead")
  - 2018_DC_Kalb_181119 Politics & Prose -- Marvin Kalb ("Enemy of the People") w/Andrea Mitchell
  - 2017_DC_Kalb_171021 Politics & Prose -- Marvin Kalb ("The Year I Was Peter the Great")
  - 2017_DC_Kalb_170408 NPC -- Kalb Report: "Fight for Freedom of the Press" (w/Jake Tapper and David Fahrenthold)
  - 2016_DC_Kalb_160420 NPC -- Kalb Report: "Covering Washington and the World" (w/Judy Woodruff)
  - 2015_DC_ReportingR_150521 Newseum -- Members' Opening for Reporting Vietnam exhibit -- Reception
  - 2015_DC_Hess_150118 Politics & Prose -- Stephen Hess ("Professor and the President")
  - 2014_DC_Kalb_141020 NPC -- Kalb Report: "Writing History" (w/Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein)
  - 2013_DC_Kalb_131122 NPC -- Kalb Report: "A Presidency: A Legacy and a Day That Changed America" (w/Dan Rather)
  - 2013_DC_Kalb_130827 NPC -- Kalb Report: "Remembering a March, a Movement and a Dream!" (w/John Lewis, Andrew Young, Julian Bond, Gwen Ifill, John Wilson, and Dorothy Gilliam)
  - ...More (List all 21 pages with this person)...
- Kalb, Claudia appears on:
  - 2018_DC_Kalb_181119 Politics & Prose -- Marvin Kalb ("Enemy of the People") w/Andrea Mitchell
  - 2016_DC_NPC_Bookfair_161118 NPC -- 39th Annual Book Fair & Author's Night (2016)
  - 2016_MD_GBF_Kalb_160521 Gaithersburg Book Festival (2016) -- Claudia Kalb ("Andy Warhol was a Hoarder")
- Kalb, Marvin appears on:
  - 2023_DC_Kalb_230722 Politics & Prose -- Deborah Kalb ("Off to Join the Circus") w/Susan Coll
  - 2023_DC_Kalb3_230422 NPC -- The Kalb Report Celebration and Lifetime Achievement Award Ceremony -- Everything Else
  - 2023_DC_Kalb_230422 NPC -- The Kalb Report Celebration and Lifetime Achievement Award Ceremony -- Program
  - 2019_DC_Berlin30_191112 Brookings Institution -- Europe 1989-2019: Lessons Learned 30 Years After The Fall Of The Berlin Wall
  - 2019_DC_Callamard_190702 Brookings Institution -- Investigating the Khashoggi murder: Insights from UN Special Rapporteur Agnes Callamard
  - 2019_DC_Kalb_190415 NPC -- Kalb Report: "50th Anniversary of the Apollo 11 Moon Landing" (w/Michael Collins)
  - 2019_DC_Kalb_190401 NPC -- Kalb Report: "A Conversation with Cokie Roberts on Democracy, Politics, and the Press" (w/Cokie Roberts)
  - 2019_DC_Kalb_190107 Politics & Prose -- Deborah Kalb and Robert Lunsford ("President and Me: John Adams & the Magic Bobblehead")
  - 2018_DC_Kalb_181119 Politics & Prose -- Marvin Kalb ("Enemy of the People") w/Andrea Mitchell
  - 2018_DC_NPC_Bookfair_181102 NPC -- 41st Annual Book Fair & Author's Night (2018)
  - ...More (List all 54 pages with this person)...
- Klein, Gil appears on:
  - 2023_DC_Kalb3_230422 NPC -- The Kalb Report Celebration and Lifetime Achievement Award Ceremony -- Everything Else
  - 2023_DC_Kalb_230422 NPC -- The Kalb Report Celebration and Lifetime Achievement Award Ceremony -- Program
  - 2019_DC_LM_GK_190112 Politics & Prose -- Lopez Matthews ("Howard University in the World Wars") and Gil Klein ("Trouble in Lafayette Square")
  - 2018_DC_NPC_Bookfair_181102 NPC -- 41st Annual Book Fair & Author's Night (2018)
  - 2017_DC_Kalb_171016 NPC -- Kalb Report: "Guardians of the Fourth Estate" (w/Dean Baquet and Marty Baron)
  - 2017_DC_Kalb_170408 NPC -- Kalb Report: "Fight for Freedom of the Press" (w/Jake Tapper and David Fahrenthold)
  - 2016_DC_Kalb_160420 NPC -- Kalb Report: "Covering Washington and the World" (w/Judy Woodruff)
  - 2015_DC_Lincoln_VisitsV_151203 DC -- Abraham Lincoln press conference @ VFW on Illinois Statehood Day
  - 2015_DC_Kalb_151109 NPC -- Kalb Report: "Sunday Talk" (w/Chuck Todd and John Dickerson)
  - 2014_DC_Kalb_141020 NPC -- Kalb Report: "Writing History" (w/Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein)
  - ...More (List all 32 pages with this person)...
- Totenberg, Nina appears on:
  - 2019_DC_Moment_Pgm_191124 DC -- Moment Magazine's 2019 Gala and Awards Dinner @ National Press Club -- Presentation
  - 2019_DC_Moment_Pre_191124 DC -- Moment Magazine's 2019 Gala and Awards Dinner @ National Press Club -- Pre-dinner mingling
  - 2018_DC_Moment_Pgm_181111 DC -- Moment Magazine's 2018 Gala and Awards Dinner @ National Press Club -- Ceremony Itself
  - 2018_DC_Moment_Dinner_181111 DC -- Moment Magazine's 2018 Gala and Awards Dinner @ National Press Club -- Dinner and Post-Event Mingling
  - 2016_DC_FioreR_160524 Library of Congress -- Ceremony: Herblock Prize (2016): Mark Fiore -- Reception (and anything non-program)
  - 2013_DC_Junkie_130116 Sixth & I and NPR -- Political Junkie Road Show: Have a Pre-Inauguration Ball
- Trachtenberg, Stephen appears on:
  - 2019_DC_Kalb_190415 NPC -- Kalb Report: "50th Anniversary of the Apollo 11 Moon Landing" (w/Michael Collins)
  - 2016_DC_Kalb_160512 NPC -- Kalb Report: "American Story: A Master Class with David McCullough"
  - 2014_DC_Kalb_140417 NPC -- Kalb Report: "45 Words" (w/Antonin Scalia and Ruth Bader Ginsburg)
- Turley, Jonathan appears on:
  - 2018_DC_Special_Counsel_181215 Newseum -- What's Special About a Special Counsel? (w/Stuart E. Eizenstat, Kenneth Starr, Jonathan Turley, Greta Van Susteren)
- Williams, Pete appears on:
  - 2016_DC_Breyer_160225 Newseum & Supreme Court Fellows Alumni Association -- Court and the World w/Stephen Breyer and Pete Williams
  - 2008_DC_Williams_080719 Newseum -- Inside Media w/Pete Williams (Justice Department coverage)
Connection Not Secure messages? Those warnings you get from your browser about this site not having secure connections worry some people. This means this site does not have SSL installed (the link is http:, not https:). That's bad if you're entering credit card numbers, passwords, or other personal information. But this site doesn't collect any personal information so SSL is not necessary. Life's good!
Photo Contact: [Email Bruce Guthrie].